Name: Chris porter
Occupation: Student
City: Lincoln, Country: US
Comments: Let free speech ring!
Date: 01-22-02 Time: 18:28 pm

Name: cheryl buxton
Occupation:
City: chester, Country: GB
Comments:
Date: 01-22-02 Time: 23:25 pm

Name: Zahed Amanullah
Occupation: Structural Engineer
City: San Francisco, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-22-02 Time: 23:55 pm

Name: Tasnim Gosla
Occupation: Student
City: Ladera Ranch, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-22-02 Time: 23:58 pm

Name: Anita Vasa
Occupation: Therapist Intern
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 00:04 am

Name: Ashish Chadha
Occupation: Student
City: Stanford University, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 00:04 am

Name: anil patwardhan
Occupation: grad student
City: san francisco, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 00:22 am

Name: Francine Viloria
Occupation: student
City: --, Country: JP
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 01:01 am

Name: Angel Roque
Occupation: Graduate Student
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 01:13 am

Name: Aditi Chowdhury
Occupation: Media Consultant
City: Hong Kong, Country: HK
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 01:29 am

Name: Veena Dubal
Occupation: student
City: San Francisco, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 01:51 am

Name: Jyotirmoy Chaudhuri
Occupation: student
City: New Delhi, Country: IN
Comments: Not again!
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 02:06 am

Name: Devyani Sharma
Occupation: student
City: Mountain View, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 02:22 am

Name: debbie townsend
Occupation: working stiff :)
City: halifax, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 03:12 am

Name: Shishir K. Jha
Occupation: Teaching
City: Mumbai, Country: IN
Comments: The need to protect sentiments of justice must come first!
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 04:00 am

Name: Geeta Citygirl
Occupation: Actor/Director
City: New York, Country: US
Comments: One Love...
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 04:41 am

Name: andrew pritchard
Occupation: writer
City: sligo, Country: IE
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 04:45 am

Name: The Baron Abbotsford (LSR/USA)
Occupation:
City: Chicago, Country: US
Comments: Manifesto 2000 Defend freedom of expression and cultural diversity, giving preference always to dialogue and listening without engaging in fanaticism, defamation and the rejection of others! http://www.unesco.org/manifesto2000/default.asp?part=ind/usa/369/uxu
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 05:02 am

Name: Naeem Zamindar
Occupation: Venture Capital
City: Santa Clara, Country: US
Comments: Diversity of view and freedom of speech with integrity of being are the cornerstone of human evolution
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 05:29 am

Name: Diana Reddy
Occupation: student
City: Houston, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 05:38 am

Name: MaryJoan D'Amore
Occupation:
City: Lancaster, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 05:39 am

Name: Sukla Sen
Occupation: Activist, EKTA (Committee for Communal Amity)
City: Bombay, Country: IN
Comments: In no way the voice of the voiceless millions of Indians, whom Anand Patwardhan persistently keeps on trying to give an audible, well articulated and aesthatically balanced voice must be gagged.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 05:55 am

Name: Chukka Srinivas
Occupation: Engineer
City: Woburn, Country: US
Comments: If anything, Anand Patwardhan movies are doing a service to the Hindu religion - by showing the real face of the Sangh Parvari brand of religio-politics - and it's perverse and bigoted interpretation of religion.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:17 am

Name: Rini Bhattacharya Mehta
Occupation: Graduate Student
City: Ithaca, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:22 am

Name: Daniel Lee
Occupation: Marketing/PR
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:22 am

Name: Parul Shah
Occupation:
City: brooklyn, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:26 am

Name: Imran Khalid-Khan
Occupation:
City: Ottawa, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:34 am

Name: Alexander R. Bay
Occupation: Graduate Student
City: Stanford, Country: US
Comments: Mr. Patwardhan's films are very powerful, very political, and have EVERYTHING to do with the state of world affairs today. To not show his films would be a step towards the type of thinking we are supposedly fighting against in Southcentral Asia today.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:40 am

Name: Shompa Datta
Occupation: Teacher
City: Tuscaloosa, Country: US
Comments: Hindu Fundamentalist is an oxymoron.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:44 am

Name: erica loomba
Occupation: Attorney
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:46 am

Name: Sahana Dharmapuri
Occupation: Media Manager
City: --, Country: US
Comments: To quote: "An injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere."
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:52 am

Name: David Clingingsmith
Occupation: Economics Graduate Student, Harvard University
City: Somerville, Country: US
Comments: I fully support and encourage the screening of Mr. Patwardhan's films and believe those who disagree with them should use public channels to express their views and not attempt to prevent others from having the opportunity to come to their own conclusions.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 06:58 am

Name: Maha Hussain
Occupation:
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 07:02 am

Name: Amitava Kumar
Occupation: Professor
City: State College, Country: US
Comments: All those who, in the name of tradition, believe in burning women, churches, and minorities, will support the muzzling of Patwardhan's brave voice.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 07:03 am

Name: Simona Mkrtschjan
Occupation: Editor
City: Chicago, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 07:06 am

Name: Ashwini Tambe
Occupation: Teaching
City: Washington D.C., Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 07:36 am

Name: Abja Midha
Occupation: Consultant
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 07:45 am

Name: Sanjay Tyagi
Occupation: Scientist
City: New York, Country: US
Comments: It is time that we resist the attempts of religious chauvinists to stifle our voice. People who are opposing the screening of these films are the same groups that raise money for right-wing extremist parties in India and have been exhorting us towards war.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 07:57 am

Name: Mridu Chandra
Occupation: Filmmaker/Writer
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 07:59 am

Name: Nandini Rajwade
Occupation: Assoc prod/ broadcast journalist(was in india- currently studying)
City: san jose, Country: US
Comments: it's quite simple really; a film maker has the right to produce his verion of society and life; NO ONE SHOULD HAVE THE RIGHT TO STOP HIM
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:06 am

Name: Christian Anderson
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:08 am

Name: Puja Lalmalani
Occupation: actor/writer/dancer
City: Brooklyn, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:09 am

Name: Rajika Bhandari
Occupation: Educational Researcher
City: --, Country: US
Comments: Anand Patwardhan's films are provocative and significant because they educate and because they address some of the most insidious problems of Indian society. It is bad enough that his films face resistance in India--it would be even worse if the Indian diaspora responds in a close-minded fashion.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:12 am

Name: Balmurli Natrajan
Occupation: Teacher
City: Ames, Country: US
Comments: Patwardan's works are not only timely but also bold, progressive and thought-provoking. They need to be aired freely.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:14 am

Name: Shelly Bahl
Occupation: Artist/ Educator
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:16 am

Name: Akhila Raman
Occupation: DSP Engineer
City: berkeley, Country: US
Comments: Protect free specch!
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:37 am

Name: R. Ezra Erb
Occupation: Student
City: Stanford, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:39 am

Name: Ashish Gupta
Occupation:
City: Pomona, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:51 am

Name: Vivek Asija
Occupation: CIO
City: San Francisco, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 08:53 am

Name: Raza Mir
Occupation: Teacher
City: Long Branch, Country: US
Comments: Anand Patwardhan's films do not attack any religion, only religious bigotry.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:04 am

Name: Madhuri Deshmukh
Occupation: Professor
City: Chicago, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:04 am

Name: Aisha Karim
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:11 am

Name: Nimish Desai
Occupation: student
City: Austin, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:16 am

Name: Pradeep Sopory
Occupation: Professor
City: Memphis, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:21 am

Name: Jisha Menon
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:26 am

Name: Iram Khandwala
Occupation: Graphic Designer
City: Chicago, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:27 am

Name: shailja sharma
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:27 am

Name: Sapna Desai
Occupation: Student
City: Boston, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:29 am

Name: Veena Singh
Occupation: doc
City: san francisco, Country: US
Comments: We can't allow fundamentalism of any kind to be ignored.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:31 am

Name: Pritam Singh
Occupation: University lecturer
City: Oxford, Country: GB
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:35 am

Name: Vivek Mittal
Occupation:
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:35 am

Name: manish mukherjee
Occupation:
City: hollywood, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:40 am

Name: Gauri Kitchlu
Occupation: Student
City: Washington, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:48 am

Name: Shalini Gera
Occupation: Consultant
City: San Jose, Country: US
Comments: Great religions are enriched by discussion and introspection, not maligned by honest criticism. The issues raised by Mr. Patwardhan's films need to be discussed in a free and open society.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:51 am

Name: Girish Agrawal
Occupation: Engineer
City: San Jose, Country: US
Comments: Please do not bow to pressure from the hate-mongering Hindu fundamentalists. The HSC, VHPA and others of their ilk are bigoted and intolerant of any views but their own--and admirers of Hitler to boot.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:54 am

Name: Dr. Vinod Mubayi
Occupation: Scientist
City: Miller Place, Country: US
Comments: The objections voiced against Anand Patwardhan's films by the so-called Hindu organizations are biased and absurd. They should be disregarded completely.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 09:54 am

Name: Anubha Kothari
Occupation:
City: Stanford, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:00 am

Name: Caesar Sengupta
Occupation:
City: Palo Alto, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:08 am

Name: sandhya pallana
Occupation: network engineer
City: oakland, Country: US
Comments: patwardhan's films bring religion into a healthy thought provoking light. we should embrace not fear our freedoms in this country, one of them being freedom of speech. i don't believe his films are against or for any specific religion, but the understanding of what atrocities can be done in the name of religion.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:13 am

Name: Sonny Gill
Occupation: Attorney
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:13 am

Name: Aniruddha Vaidya
Occupation: Computer Engineer
City: Mountain View, Country: US
Comments: I have seen and been inspired by the several Anand Patwardhan films. Anand Patwardhan's films teach us much about what is ailing India and South Asia today : the pillage of public resources, big dams, religous and caste bigotry and the rise of Hindu fundamentalism. His films need to be watched by anyone interested in South Asia and everyone in India as it holds a mirror to our faces and the image does not make a pretty picture.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:40 am

Name: hitchhiker intergalactic
Occupation: engineer
City: palo alto, Country: US
Comments: PROTECT FREE SPEECH!!
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:41 am

Name: dushyant pandya
Occupation: Marketing
City: Palo Alto, Country: US
Comments: Freedom of speech and religious tolerance are the hallmark of civilized society.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:47 am

Name: Rajesh Veeraraghavan
Occupation: Software Design Engineer
City: Saratoga, Country: US
Comments: Protect Free Speech. And don't allow the hindu fundamentalist to hijack any agenda.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:47 am

Name: Alka Hingorani
Occupation: Student
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:50 am

Name: shrikanth shankar
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:53 am

Name: Yamini Nayar
Occupation: artist/writer
City: Brooklyn, Country: US
Comments: our voice is all we have. when it's stomped upon, we walk into a tunnel of dark.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:55 am

Name: Anirvan Chatterjee
Occupation: CEO
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments: Petitions and counter-petitions are nothing more than popularity contests. Patwardhan's films should be screened because they're relevant, not because people are willing to write in to support them. Squelching debate is always a bad idea.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:57 am

Name: Supratik Chakraborty
Occupation: Teaching and research
City: --, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 10:59 am

Name: radhika xxx
Occupation:
City: san francisco, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:00 am

Name: MAnisha Nair
Occupation: Eng
City: Santa Clara, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:07 am

Name: Lauren Hotchkiss
Occupation: writer/musician
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments: Preventing film screenings is just one step away from blacklisting. Do we really wish to resurrect the spirit of McCarthyism?
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:11 am

Name: Prasad Vaidya
Occupation: Energy Analyst
City: minneapolis, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:20 am

Name: vinod chandnani
Occupation: web developer
City: columbus, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:26 am

Name: Anjum Ansari
Occupation:
City: Oak Park, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:36 am

Name: Maharaj K. Kaul
Occupation:
City: Fremont, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:43 am

Name: mona chopra
Occupation:
City: new york, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:48 am

Name: Ali Kazimi
Occupation: filmmaker
City: --, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:56 am

Name: Ali Mir
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 11:59 am

Name: Prashant Jawalikar
Occupation: Programmer
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:00 pm

Name: Mishka Zaman
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:07 pm

Name: Shailaja Menon
Occupation: Student
City: Ann Arbor, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:19 pm

Name: Arvind Raghavan
Occupation:
City: Camarillo, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:19 pm

Name: Siddharth Shah
Occupation: Physician
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:22 pm

Name: Kinkini Banerjee
Occupation: Nutritionist
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:26 pm

Name: Vidhya Muthuram
Occupation:
City: Washington DC, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:37 pm

Name: Srividhya Venkataraman
Occupation: Engineer
City: Saratoga, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:47 pm

Name: Roland Hsu
Occupation: College adviser
City: Chicago, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:48 pm

Name: Sarika Seth
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:50 pm

Name: Karuna Morarji
Occupation:
City: Olympia, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 12:59 pm

Name: Sameena Vaseem
Occupation: student at Cal
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments: Patwardhan is THE leading documentary filmmaker from India. Do not silence his images of truth!
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 13:22 pm

Name: Shaheen Tarafder
Occupation: Software Engineer
City: Forest Hills, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 13:35 pm

Name: Rahul Gudla
Occupation: Engineer
City: San Jose, Country: US
Comments: Anand Patwardhan's moview are eye-openers
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 13:35 pm

Name: Birjinder Anant
Occupation:
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 13:47 pm

Name: Karuna Muthiah
Occupation:
City: Foster City, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 13:49 pm

Name: Bhaskaran Raman
Occupation: Graduate Student
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments: Branding is an easy way to reject arguments. That's what the people who brand Anand Patwardhan a "self-proclaimed leftist" are doing.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 13:52 pm

Name: Anand Raghavan
Occupation:
City: Sunnyvale, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 14:02 pm

Name: Shalini Eddens
Occupation: program manager-public health
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 14:19 pm

Name: Amit C.
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments: Let the Hindutva brigade counter speech with speech openly. They have no divine right -- though they have repeatedly attempted to exercise it in any case -- to stifle the public discourse. Their methods, from barring screenings to attacking film sets to burning books, prove that they belong to their beloved Middle Ages far more than to pluralistic, democratic life.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 14:21 pm

Name: Reva Patwardhan
Occupation:
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 14:29 pm

Name: Radhika Sehgal
Occupation: Student
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 14:35 pm

Name: Shashikanth Suryanarayanan
Occupation: Student
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments: Right to expression has to be protected expressly! Moreover, Anand's films are cool :-))
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 15:21 pm

Name: Joyoni Dey
Occupation: Engineer
City: Sunnyvale, Country: US
Comments: I saw both the documentaries. I did not feel the film maker demeaned Hinduism in anyway. He just wanted to point out injustices in the name of religion.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 15:29 pm

Name: Susmita Das
Occupation: student
City: SF, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 15:30 pm

Name: Patrick McCully
Occupation: Environmentalist
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments: Patwardhan's films are important - and freedom of speech is important.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 15:30 pm

Name: Jith Meganathan
Occupation: Student
City: Somerville, Country: US
Comments: To those who oppose Mr.Patwardhan's work: why not seek a forum in which you can express disagreement with his views, rather than pursuing suppression? We would benefit from hearing all sides.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 15:33 pm

Name: Manjri Sewak
Occupation: Graduate Student Conflict Transformation Eastern Mennonite University 1200 Park Road Harrisonburg, VA 22802
City: Harrisonburg, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 15:54 pm

Name: brinda sarathy
Occupation:
City: oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 16:30 pm

Name: Chris Anderson
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 16:49 pm

Name: Lata Iyer
Occupation:
City: Redlands, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 16:56 pm

Name: Manish Desai
Occupation:
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 17:06 pm

Name: Rahul De'
Occupation: Educator
City: Lawrenceville, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 17:09 pm

Name: Urmila Mohan
Occupation: Communication Designer
City: --, Country: US
Comments: Dear Elaine, This is to express my support for the screening of Anant's films at the AMNH. I remember seeing Anant Patwardhan at school in India and recommend his film 'Ram Ke Naam' (In the name of God) to all people concerned with the rise of fundamentalism worldwide and the freedom of the artist/documentor. I resent the idea that any one group of people can speak or be outraged on behalf of an entire community! The truth is that fundamentalism & religious revivalism are alive & kicking in India. To force the censorship of documentation/commentary is just a disgusting strongarm tactic. Such censorship seems to target literary or artistic interpretations of texts like the Ramayana, that do not agree with the majority. There is no One Ramayana, just like there is no One way to live as a Hindu. I hope that the exhbition will continue as originally planned. That will give me some hope that hindu fundamentalism although imported to the US cannot take permanent root in this country.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 17:19 pm

Name: Srinath Alapati
Occupation: IT Specialist
City: San Jose, CA, Country: US
Comments: I have not seen this particular film, but I have seen many films made by him. I strongly encourage showing this film. He is very objective.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 17:23 pm

Name: Abdulrahman Rafiq
Occupation: Engineer
City: Santa Clara, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 17:26 pm

Name: Sunil Deshmukh
Occupation: Wall Street Commodity Trader
City: Stamford, Country: US
Comments: India is on the brink of fascism. All progressive people and orgs have to support courageous progressive artists like Anand at this critical juncture
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 17:58 pm

Name: Nuraini Arsad
Occupation: research assistant
City: Skudai, Country: MY
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 18:16 pm

Name: Maya Manian
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments: There is a dire lack of information regarding the rise of hindu fundamentalism in India.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 18:19 pm

Name: Gisele Gordon
Occupation: Filmmaker
City: Toronto, Country: CA
Comments: Anand Patwardhan's work is crucial. He has the courage to show the tragic repurcussions of power hungry politicians' manipulation of ethnic and class divisions to further their own ends. His work needs to be seen by as many people as possible.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 18:27 pm

Name: Cameron Bailey
Occupation: Film critic
City: Toronto, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 18:37 pm

Name: Purnima Manghnani
Occupation:
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 18:40 pm

Name: Aparna Devare
Occupation:
City: ROCKVILLE, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 19:00 pm

Name: Vijay Iyer
Occupation: musician
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 20:13 pm

Name: Gautam Sen
Occupation: Teacher
City: Istanbul, Country: TR
Comments: At a time when all kinds of things are being swept under the label of terrorism, it is important to distinguish the REAL terrorists. Patwardhan's films on the Hindu fascists help in making this distinction. Moreover, I agree with the person who asks Patwardhan's opponenents to debate their views openly rather than rely on fascist tactics.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 20:14 pm

Name: Anjali Kamat
Occupation: teacher
City: oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 20:23 pm

Name: Subhradip Ghosh
Occupation: Research scholar
City: Highland Park, Country: US
Comments: I wholeheartedly support the screening of Anand Patwardhan's film. The succesful screening would be one step ahead to combat the religious fascists back in India and their overseas friends.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 20:26 pm

Name: Lizette Lim
Occupation:
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 20:37 pm

Name: Rita Mazumdar
Occupation: Teacher
City: Ranchi, Country: IN
Comments: Freedom of expression must not be stiffled. Patwardhan should have right to screen his films in India or abroad
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 20:50 pm

Name: Sumita Sen
Occupation: fianance & marketing/student-screenplay writing
City: --, Country: US
Comments: Have seen several of Mr Patwardhans films..have gained valuable information and feel it would be a terrible mistake if in any shape of form they were made unavailable to the public
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 20:54 pm

Name: Ricardo Acosta
Occupation: Film Editor
City: Tooronto, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 20:58 pm

Name: Iftikhar Chaudhry
Occupation: Engineer
City: Santa Rosa, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 21:31 pm

Name: Kiran Patel
Occupation:
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments: There's room for all of us. I appreciate Mr. Patwardhan creating a space in the film medium to represent underrepresented perspectives on critical matters that affect many. Let's not silence this rare voice. Instead, let's open our ears, our hearts and minds and let these voices enter our souls.
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 22:10 pm

Name: Hatem Radwan
Occupation: Engineer
City: San Jose, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 22:11 pm

Name: Syed Asif
Occupation: Financial Analyst
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 22:59 pm

Name: husain akbar
Occupation: cameraperson
City: new delhi, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 23:02 pm

Name: florence yoo
Occupation:
City: new york, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-23-02 Time: 23:02 pm

Name: Ramesh Dodamani
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 00:31 am

Name: Lehar Hind
Occupation: Management and Development consultant.
City: SFO/ New Delhi, Country: IN
Comments: Freedom of Speech is part of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. No Talibani group, 'Moslem', 'Hindu'or Christian should be allowed to get way with this kind of attack on human liberties. The United States has been a champion of civil liberites and freedom of speech since the American War of Independence. We hope that it will not let us, the international and US community, down.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 01:37 am

Name: Anibel Ferus-Comelo
Occupation:
City: --, Country: GB
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 01:42 am

Name: Meena Dhanda
Occupation: University Lecturer
City: Oxford, Country: GB
Comments: I have seen two of Patwardan's previous documentary films and both were excellent: very perceptive and very well made. I look forward to seeing the latest one when it comes to the UK. It is ridiculous to call for a ban on something that could improve our understanding of ourselves!
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 04:44 am

Name: Felicia Craig
Occupation:
City: Middletown, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 05:22 am

Name: Kirankumar Vissa
Occupation: Communications Engineer, and volunteer for Association for India's Development
City: College Park, Country: US
Comments: I have seen both these films and also a few other films of Anand Patwardhan. They are excellent documentaries and bring to light facts with a lot of clarity. They are a must-see for everyone who wants to form an opinion on the issues involved - in this particular case the Hindutva ideology, the Ayodhya tangle and Dalit perspective. Given that very few Indians in the US refrain from having an opinion on these matters, it is all the more essential for these to be screened widely and publicly.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 06:16 am

Name: Anwar Kazimi
Occupation: Public service
City: Toronto, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 06:44 am

Name: Sumita Bhandari
Occupation: Attorney
City: Washington D.C., Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 06:54 am

Name: rohit tripathi
Occupation:
City: germantown, Country: US
Comments: All power to Anand for his great work!
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 07:03 am

Name: Tulika Narayan
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 07:20 am

Name: Tarun Jain
Occupation:
City: Washington, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 07:26 am

Name: Manu Mathai
Occupation: Graduate Student
City: College Park, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 07:28 am

Name: Ambar Narayan
Occupation: Economist
City: --, Country: US
Comments: I have always found Anand's work impressive and thought-provoking, even when I haven't agreed with him (particularly on globalization). I absolutely condemn any effort to silence his voice. To the would-be censors (every community has its "talibans"): are you intellectually incapable of engaging in a constructive debate, or are your beliefs too irrational (even to you) to take that "risk"?
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 07:36 am

Name: Madhu Raghunath
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 07:41 am

Name: Rahul Rajkumar
Occupation: Medical Student
City: New Haven, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 07:58 am

Name: Joseph McKenzie
Occupation: Retired Professor
City: Fredericton,, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 07:59 am

Name: Ashim Jain
Occupation: Engineer
City: San Jose, Country: US
Comments: Freedom & democracy is the birth right of every human being - which can never become a reality without free speech.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:05 am

Name: Rajeev Natarajan
Occupation: Graduate Student and volunteer for Association for India's Development
City: College Park, Country: US
Comments: I think his movies depict the problems in a perspective that needs to reach out to more people. The fact that there are groups that have called a ban shows some element of fear in terms of the repercussion that they might face...
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:15 am

Name: Ashok Bhargava
Occupation: Professor of Economics
City: Madison, Country: US
Comments: I am currently writing a review of Anand's films. Good luck with the petition.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:17 am

Name: narayan iyer
Occupation: Entrepreneur
City: owings mills, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:17 am

Name: Pradyumna Singh
Occupation: Graduate Student
City: Newark, Country: US
Comments: Views can be questioned, but anyone's right to express those views is beyond contention.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:20 am

Name: Powell Jose
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:25 am

Name: Ravishankar Arunachalam
Occupation: Engineer
City: Austin, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:32 am

Name: Nandini Gupta
Occupation: Research Scientist
City: Eindhoven, Country: NL
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:34 am

Name: Ayesha emad
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:34 am

Name: Ann Tanner
Occupation: Secretary
City: Glasgow, Country: GB
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:44 am

Name: Ravi Kanitkar
Occupation: Engineer
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:54 am

Name: Amit Mukherjee
Occupation: Graduate Student University of Maryland, College Park USA
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 08:58 am

Name: Prita Subramanian
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 09:22 am

Name: Sabine Meier
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 09:53 am

Name: Isabelle Valois
Occupation: Development practionner
City: Ottawa, Country: CA
Comments: Anand's film always provide with a different and often missing perspective on different social issues.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 10:03 am

Name: Kausik Sarkar
Occupation: asst prof (mech. eng.)
City: newark, Country: US
Comments: free speech should be protected
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 10:04 am

Name: kalpa shah
Occupation: Student
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 10:07 am

Name: Jason J Green
Occupation:
City: Stanardsville, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 10:14 am

Name: Irfan Mufti
Occupation: Development Activist
City: Lahore, Country: PK
Comments: I fully support the concept of the film made by Anand.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 10:25 am

Name: Sayantan Biswas
Occupation: Graduate Student
City: Washington D.C.,, Country: US
Comments: Anand Patwardhan is one those few people who are dealing with issues, which are unheard or ignored by many of us. This intention to curb his voice is highly undemocartic.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 10:48 am

Name: charulatha venkataraman
Occupation: graduate student
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 10:55 am

Name: Dr. Aurangzeb Syed
Occupation: Professor
City: Marquette, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 10:57 am

Name: Vidhi Parthasarathy
Occupation:
City: madison, Country: US
Comments: free speech should be protected
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:02 am

Name: Faris Ahmed
Occupation:
City: --, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:05 am

Name: Mamta Ahluwalia
Occupation:
City: Stanford, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:10 am

Name: Anurag Acharya
Occupation: Software Engineer
City: Mountain View, Country: US
Comments: Anand is an insightful filmmaker. His documentaries explore complex issues and usually reach the core of the matter at hand.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:18 am

Name: Sriram Srinivasan
Occupation: Software engineer
City: berkeley, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:22 am

Name: Ashwin Baskaran
Occupation:
City: Petaluma, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:23 am

Name: Om P. Damani
Occupation: Computer Scientist
City: Cambridge, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:26 am

Name: Samir C
Occupation:
City: Wash DC, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:38 am

Name: Mira Nair
Occupation: film director
City: new york, Country: US
Comments: patwardhan is a great political film-maker and must be seen and heard in as many places as can possibly determine!
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:46 am

Name: Veena Gokhale
Occupation: NGO worker
City: Ottawa, Country: CA
Comments: I absolutely support freedom of speech and expression and the screening of Anand Patwardhan's films in the U.S. I first got to know Anand's work in the mid-80s, as a journalist in Bombay and have followed his career since. I think his work is relevant and good and deserves wide exposure and discussion.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 11:49 am

Name: Chitra Ranganathan
Occupation: Student
City: Columbus, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 12:13 pm

Name: Sankar Sitaraman
Occupation: Professor
City: --, Country: US
Comments: We should let the right wing know that most Indians (Hindus, especially) don't support their fundamentalist policies
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 12:22 pm

Name: Shundell Prasad
Occupation: Film Student New York University
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 12:35 pm

Name: Barnali Ghosh
Occupation: Landscape Architect
City: berkeley, Country: US
Comments: We have to learn to face reality.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 12:55 pm

Name: Ratna Sengupta
Occupation: Engineer
City: --, Country: US
Comments: As a secular humanist I would recommend showing Patwardhan's film in every country.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 13:04 pm

Name: Phong Tran
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 13:06 pm

Name: Sakina Sadat Hussain
Occupation:
City: Seattle, Country: US
Comments: Art is free and films, such as those directed by Patwardhan, are always an eye-opener in many ways. Efforts to ban the screening only proves that fundamentalism kills creativity and free speech.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 13:32 pm

Name: Balram Sampla
Occupation:
City: Rochester, Country: GB
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 13:47 pm

Name: Saurabh Lodha
Occupation: Graduate Student
City: West Lafayette, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 13:48 pm

Name: francis kombarakaran
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 13:57 pm

Name: Dhanada Mishra
Occupation:
City: Sydney, Country: AU
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 13:58 pm

Name: Courtney Cswercko
Occupation:
City: Slater, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 14:25 pm

Name: Deepak Lall
Occupation:
City: Union City, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 14:54 pm

Name: Shilpa Joshi
Occupation:
City: Brookline, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 15:30 pm

Name: Tabrez shaikh
Occupation: student
City: Toledo, Country: US
Comments: After meddling with history now the hardliners want to obscure current facts! Its a duty to thwart their gimmicks.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 15:38 pm

Name: Siva Digavalli
Occupation: Scientist
City: ROCKYHILL, Country: US
Comments: I have seen these videos and they are very interesting. Not withstanding their merit, Mr.Patwardhan, or for that matter any artist, should have an open forum to express him/herself.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 15:39 pm

Name: Ritwik Bhatia
Occupation:
City: West Lafayette, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 15:39 pm

Name: Michelle Oja
Occupation:
City: Lincoln, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 15:51 pm

Name: Kavita Philip
Occupation: Academic
City: atlanta, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 16:18 pm

Name: Robert Gill
Occupation: University Professor
City: Toronto, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 16:20 pm

Name: Meetali Jain
Occupation: attorney
City: San Francisco, Country: US
Comments: Patwardhan's films must be protected for provoking critical dialogue in a time of simplistic rhetoric.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 16:24 pm

Name: Shridhar Reddy
Occupation: Student
City: Atlanta, Country: US
Comments: As a Communication student years ago in Hyderabad, it was Patwardhan's "Father son... " that shook me up to social realities in India and of the power of film-makers to help reflect and interpret these realities. But why should hindu right-wingers in the US want to oppose screenings of his films?! I thought that Indians here would be free from fundamentalist delusions. All the more reason that his films should be screened!
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 16:29 pm

Name: Tracye Sine
Occupation: Inventory Auditor
City: Huntsville, Country: US
Comments: I have not had the pleasure of viewing any of Anand Patwardhan's films, but I wish there were more venues for non-mainstream film. If religious people were truly confident in their faiths, an opposing viewpoint would not be cause for such protest.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 16:46 pm

Name: sally matsukawa
Occupation: cashier
City: bellflower, Country: US
Comments: freedom of spech is what this country is all about... freedom.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 17:03 pm

Name: Elizabeth Garone
Occupation: Journalist
City: Oakland, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 17:57 pm

Name: Patricia O'Leary
Occupation: Teacher
City: College Park, Country: US
Comments: I have not yet viewed any of his films, but would do so at the first opportunity.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 18:01 pm

Name: Magnus Isacsson
Occupation: filmmaker
City: Montreal, Country: CA
Comments: Anand's work is exemplary, and this campaign to defend freedom of expression is essential.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 18:03 pm

Name: Manon Hogue
Occupation: Journalist and film-maker
City: Montreal, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 18:22 pm

Name: Subramaniam Vincent
Occupation: Communications engineer
City: Bangalore, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 18:32 pm

Name: I.K. Shukla
Occupation: Litterateur
City: Los Angeles, Country: US
Comments: Any gag on Patwardhan films would only embolden the HinduTaliban stalking the land. His concerns, his commitment to social justice, his purposive filmcraft help educate and enlighten people.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 18:32 pm

Name: Sraboni Ghose
Occupation: Post doctoral fellow
City: Palo Alto, Country: US
Comments: Let the people who see the films decide for themselves.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 18:36 pm

Name: Arun Jain
Occupation: Physician
City: Boston, Country: US
Comments: I completely and whole heartedly agree with this petition.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 18:42 pm

Name: Vivek Nirkhe
Occupation: Software Engg.
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 18:54 pm

Name: Amit Puniyani
Occupation: student
City: Stanford, Country: US
Comments: Hinduism like any other religeon or dogma can be and has been hijacked by the vested interests of a small bunch of elites. Anand's films show this side of the story of Hinduism and must be screened.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 19:01 pm

Name: Marc-Antoine Parent
Occupation: Software Engineer
City: Ottawa, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 19:17 pm

Name: s j
Occupation: student
City: --, Country: US
Comments: The US Second Generation of Indians are unaware of how much they have grown up within a fundamental Hindu milieu. It seems that the Indians from India, living through senseless riots all the time, are much more attuned to the fundamentalism in their midst. A. Patwardhan obviously highlights this, and this is displeasing to the funders of the Shiv Sena who live in the comfort of their New Jersey residences.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 19:22 pm

Name: Dharma Tejus
Occupation: Engineer
City: San Jose, Country: US
Comments: Bringing out the negative aspects of a religion can help make it better. Stifling all criticisms will only deepen any decay.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 19:30 pm

Name: Amita Jha
Occupation: Physician
City: --, Country: US
Comments: Arts and creativity should not have to bear the burden of religious dogma. It should be allowed uncurtailed expression and exhibition. People whose religious beliefs systems are affected negatively by opinions or view points because of such expression have the freedom to not watch.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 20:01 pm

Name: Linda Hess
Occupation: professor
City: --, Country: US
Comments: Patwardhan is a courageous and internationally acclaimed filmmaker whose films have been very valuable to me as an educator. I also show the Sagar Ramayana videos and other sympathetic insider representations of Hinduism. But the self-appointed thought police of the right seek to suppress the art and literature that they disapprove of and to control access to information. India stands for democracy. It will be truly against India's interests and image in the world if such forces succeed in suppressing free speech, academic and artistic expression. I hope the AMNH doesn't cave in.
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 21:19 pm

Name: Chandana Mathur
Occupation:
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 21:32 pm

Name: suma veerabhadraiah
Occupation: student
City: sanjose, Country: US
Comments: free speech that inspires critical social discourse is always welcome
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 21:52 pm

Name: Sanjana Chopra
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 21:57 pm

Name: Megan Pugh
Occupation: teacher
City: Kwangyang, Country: KP
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 22:28 pm

Name: Ijaz Syed
Occupation: Consultant
City: San Jose, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 23:00 pm

Name: sayan gupta
Occupation: Research Student
City: Bangalore, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 23:37 pm

Name: myra syed
Occupation: teacher
City: Irvine, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-24-02 Time: 23:56 pm

Name: Beena Sarwar
Occupation: Journalist
City: Karachi, Country: PK
Comments: Anand's films should be shown not only on the national television network in India, but also in Pakistan where the issues he addresses are equally relevant. There is little difference between our religious right and that which exists in India.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 01:02 am

Name: Lawrence Friedman
Occupation: scientist
City: Delft, Country: NL
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 02:13 am

Name: Ziad Asim
Occupation: Technology Consultant
City: Karachi, Country: PK
Comments: This displays clearly : what they Think, What They Say, What they Actually DO........!!!
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 02:34 am

Name: Tony Dowmunt
Occupation: Teacher and producer
City: --, Country: GB
Comments: In the current global climate, spaces for these kinds of messages to be aired are vital to human survival.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 03:11 am

Name: Ram Puniyani
Occupation: Teaching
City: --, Country: IN
Comments: I strongly endorse the appeal
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 03:33 am

Name: Ahmed Salim
Occupation: Writer, Poet, Civil Society Activist.
City: Islamabad, Country: PK
Comments: I srongly support the petition.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 03:39 am

Name: Himanshu Thakkar
Occupation: Research
City: Delhi, Country: IN
Comments: It will be a sad day if such anti democratic attempts succeeed.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 04:03 am

Name: Anjali Sagar
Occupation: Producer / Artist
City: London, Country: GB
Comments: In brief, Anand's work should be respected not only for the message, then for the years of energy he puts into the making of his films. Don't these idiots who oppose the film War and Peace have anything better to do??
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 04:08 am

Name: marianne martin
Occupation: Language teacher
City: Berlin, Country: DE
Comments: Protection of free speech is a necessary and eternal fight, it will not go unnoticed.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 04:44 am

Name: Sumit Basu
Occupation: Research Scientist
City: Eindhoven, Country: NL
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 05:06 am

Name: Jhilli Biswas
Occupation: Filmmaker
City: Calcutta, Country: IN
Comments: The whole buisness of curbing democratic expressions is severely condemnable
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 05:10 am

Name: judy jackson
Occupation: documentary film makers
City: Toronto, Country: CA
Comments: We have seen over and over the consequence of curbing freedom of expression. Think about Rwanda. Think about Afghanistan. Think about Kosovo
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 05:30 am

Name: larry hughsam
Occupation: accountant
City: toronto, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 06:34 am

Name: Kavitha Nellore
Occupation: Graduate student, Penn State University
City: State College, Country: US
Comments: I hope the museum will definetely screen these movies
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 06:42 am

Name: Sreeram Pydah
Occupation: Founder and CEO of a High Tech. Company
City: Burlington, Country: US
Comments: Freedom of speech and expression is the very foundation to Intellectual progress, and any efforts to curb it should be strongly opposed.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 06:45 am

Name: Naren Kumarakulasingam
Occupation: Researcher
City: Washington, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 06:45 am

Name: sam mehta
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 07:12 am

Name: V. Kripa Sundar
Occupation: Software Engineer
City: Marlborough, Country: US
Comments: Hatred and intolerance have no part in civil society.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 07:19 am

Name: Richard McGill Murphy
Occupation: Writer, editor, producer
City: New York, Country: US
Comments: This man has important things to say. Disagree if you like, but please give him a forum.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 07:24 am

Name: Gina Moore
Occupation: student
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 07:29 am

Name: Ute Winston
Occupation: teacher
City: Tuscaloosa, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 07:36 am

Name: J. Sri Raman
Occupation: Journalism
City: --, Country: IN
Comments: The Indian or avowedly 'Hindu' fascism, notable above all for its ignorant contempt for India's history and heritage, is even more obnoxious when it goes 'phoren', when it combines the worst features of an oppressive majoritarianism at home and an insular minorityism abroad.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 07:45 am

Name: Valerie Busch
Occupation: Homemaker
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 07:59 am

Name: Claudie Gosselin
Occupation: policy analyst
City: Ottawa, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 08:28 am

Name: Deepa Rathnam Nirmal
Occupation: Interactive Designer
City: St. Paul, Country: US
Comments: Kudos for striving to protect the freedom of speech! Let Mr. Patwardhan be seen and heard and the viewers decide for themselves.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 08:29 am

Name: yasmeen fatimah
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 08:36 am

Name: Dane Kuppinger
Occupation: graduate student
City: Chapel Hill, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 08:48 am

Name: Radhika Rammohan
Occupation: Software Engineer and Volunteer with Association for India's Development
City: Atlanta, Country: US
Comments: I STRONGLY support this petition.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 08:49 am

Name: Priti Kumar
Occupation: Research Assistant
City: Canton, Country: US
Comments: We must be open to all view points before we form our own.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 09:08 am

Name: Anita Balasubramanian
Occupation: DSP Engineer
City: Bellevue, WA, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 09:09 am

Name: Sana Shaikh
Occupation: Software Engineer
City: --, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 09:20 am

Name: Prachi S Jawalikar
Occupation: Travel Agent
City: Atlanta, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 10:01 am

Name: Anjli Tantod
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 10:26 am

Name: Savita Kini
Occupation: Software Engineer
City: Santa Clara, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 10:48 am

Name: Kamal Ahmed
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 11:04 am

Name: momo h
Occupation:
City: berlin, Country: DE
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 11:08 am

Name: Susan Chacko
Occupation: scientist
City: Bethesda, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 11:13 am

Name: Jill Keesbury
Occupation: Researcher
City: Honolulu, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 11:17 am

Name: Swati Sharan
Occupation:
City: St. John's, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 11:44 am

Name: punee gupta
Occupation: Student
City: University park, Country: US
Comments: I support Dr. Anand Patwardhan and would like the screenings of his films to continue. If he can tell us something, then we MUST know it...and no one has the right to deny us that information. LET THE TRUTH PREVAIL...LET THE AUDIENCE DECIDE...dont let authenticity die like this.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 12:17 pm

Name: Jan Tarlin
Occupation: College Professor
City: Jackson, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 12:27 pm

Name: kodwo eshun
Occupation: Author and cultural critic.
City: London, Country: GB
Comments: At a critical moment like this, the films of a director such as Patwardhan are more neccessary than ever.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 12:39 pm

Name: Kaushalya Bannerji
Occupation:
City: Ottawa, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 12:44 pm

Name: Pawan Hegde
Occupation: Engineer
City: Atlanta, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 12:57 pm

Name: Vidur Sahney
Occupation: Optical Engineer
City: Sunnyvale, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 13:15 pm

Name: Nandini Chandrashekar
Occupation:
City: Mountain View, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 13:35 pm

Name: Dede Oetomo
Occupation:
City: Surabaya, Country: ID
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 15:24 pm

Name: Arnab K Chanda
Occupation: Investment Banker
City: San Francisco, Country: US
Comments: We need to have progressive and secular Indians remind us from time to time that secularism is one of the two basic components of Indian nationhood as such cannot be compromised.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 16:45 pm

Name: Ayaz Ahmed
Occupation:
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 17:20 pm

Name: Sameer Samudra
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 17:25 pm

Name: DR. Anis Alam
Occupation: Professor of Physics at the University of the Punjab
City: Lahore, Country: PK
Comments: I wholeheartedly support the campaign.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 17:37 pm

Name: Cecil Chaudhry
Occupation: Principal, St. Anthony's College
City: Lahore, Country: PK
Comments: I fully support this petition
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 18:14 pm

Name: Kalpana Sutaria
Occupation: Architect
City: Austin, Country: US
Comments: I fully support this petition. Anand has courage to make films which tell the truth about our society.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 18:43 pm

Name: Asad Zaidi
Occupation: Writer
City: --, Country: IN
Comments: I wholeheartedly endorse the petition.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 19:12 pm

Name: Lesley Esteves
Occupation: Content provider, web site developer, member of non-profit collective working for rights of Indian sexuality minorities
City: New Delhi, Country: IN
Comments: Anand Patwardhan is a precious citizen of a democratic country whose medaeval political class violates with impunity every day, the rights of India's citizens. When it comes to corruption and nepotism, there are no divisions along party lines in India. Anand Patwardhan's commitment to questioning the staggeringly inappropriate authority the Indian state imposes on citizens, to questioning those who make use of sectarian violence towards political ends, is unwavering. The current attempts to censor his participation is an indication of the terror this honest man inflicts on India's corrupt political class. His right to expression, to question evil, must not be tampered with to appease the evildoers.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 19:27 pm

Name: Deepak Malghan
Occupation: Doctoral Student
City: College Park, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 19:35 pm

Name: srikanth voorakaranam
Occupation:
City: Dallas, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 21:22 pm

Name: Ayan Banerjee
Occupation:
City: San Francisco, Country: US
Comments: The Truth is a powerful weapon...
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 21:29 pm

Name: Robin Khundkar
Occupation: Finance Professional
City: --, Country: US
Comments: Anand Patwardhan is one of the foremost Indian Documentary Filmmakers. His work is an act of conscience and must not be censored in any way.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 21:48 pm

Name: Shruti Nagar
Occupation: telivision Writer
City: Mumbai, Country: IN
Comments: It is a shame that film makers are not allowed to do thier job!!! Another case which comes to mind is that of Tahmineh Milani from Irani. A woman film maker, she is facing threat of execution, because her film has angered the ruling community of her country! Those who believe in freedom of expression, please visit http://www.thepetitionsite.com/takeaction/683717633 to support her cause.
Date: 01-25-02 Time: 23:12 pm

Name: Aditya Bondyopadhyay
Occupation: Human Rights Lawyer, Activist for Sexual Minority Rights and rights of HIV positive persons.
City: New Delhi, Country: IN
Comments: By not getting influenced by the protests against the screening of the movies, maybe we would send out the message that there are people here who would do their utmost to resist the facsi-ization of liberal democratic and diverse India. It is fundamentally important for the continued survival of free speech in India.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 00:59 am

Name: Rajiv Dua
Occupation: Independent Consultant
City: Thane, Country: IN
Comments: Let each have its say
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 01:31 am

Name: Jim Holdom
Occupation: Retired taecher of 5-6 yr olds. Human Rights activist.
City: Hamilton, Country: NZ
Comments: All perspectives should be open to be espoused, and, to be critcised. Censorship is by definition undesirable, for it prevents open examination of all perspectives/programmes, etc, and it is only by such examination that we are likely to more or less get things right.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 02:55 am

Name: Satish Saberwal
Occupation: academic
City: Delhi, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 03:36 am

Name: Khaled Hassan
Occupation: Student
City: Claremont, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 04:08 am

Name: Arindam Ghatak
Occupation: student
City: Pune, Country: IN
Comments: I have seen three of Anand's films and they are truly thought-provoking and unpretentious. In no way, can we allow the political and religious fanatics to dictate to us what can be censored and what cannot be. That is a private matter. I wholly support this cause and earnestly demand that Anand's films be shown.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 04:21 am

Name: Ravi Kumar
Occupation: student
City: Nagpur, Country: IN
Comments: nothing...........
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 04:31 am

Name: Nickie Shah
Occupation:
City: Edison, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 04:54 am

Name: Neil Pate
Occupation: News Paper, Reporter
City: Pune, Country: IN
Comments: I haven't seen any of his films, but no group, particularly religious fanatics has a right to dictate `Terms' on somebody elses piece of `Artwork'. Its high time these `Culture Vultures'learn to appreciate creativity from a fresh perspective. Because all they do is change the names of railway stations and bus terminus, which have nothing to do with creativity nor our famous warriors. Say What?
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 05:17 am

Name: Vamsi Veeramachaneni
Occupation: Doctoral student
City: State College, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 05:33 am

Name: TOM Crews
Occupation: English/Spanish Teacher
City: Columbus, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 05:41 am

Name: Sujit Patwardhan
Occupation: Graphic Designer, Printer and Environmentalist
City: Pune, Country: IN
Comments: I whole-heartedly support this petition for the right to free speach and freedom to speak out against the inhuman policies by the (any) state and for the right to work for a more humane society worldwide, which is the goal of people like Anand Patwardhan.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 09:25 am

Name: Venkatesh Iyer
Occupation:
City: Newark, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 09:39 am

Name: Swadesh Mitter Mahajan
Occupation:
City: Austin, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 09:57 am

Name: Jeet Thayil
Occupation: Writer
City: New York, Country: US
Comments: Whether or not I agree with Mr Patwardhan's point of view, I am on his side againt those who would seek to shut him up.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 10:20 am

Name: Udit Chaudhuri
Occupation: Tech Writer
City: Mumbai, Country: IN
Comments: I support this petition for the right to speak out against inhuman policies, be it anywhere. I thereby support the endeavour of people like Anand Patwardhan in building a just civilisation.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 10:22 am

Name: Karamatullah K. Ghori
Occupation: Retired Pakistani Ambassador
City: Toronto, Ontario, Country: CA
Comments: India and Pakistan have both suffered enormously on account of bigotry, fanaticism and fascism in politics. In the interest of communal harmony in either state, and for the sake of peace between them these nihilistic trends must come to an end.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 10:52 am

Name: Ashwini Pawar
Occupation: Artist
City: Lawrenceville, Country: US
Comments: I totally support the right to free speech ! I have seen a couple of documentary films by Anand Patwardhan in the past; one of them being "In the name of God". And even that tiny glimpse of his work in the arts makes me sign this petition (to support his film screenings in India or wherever), with a sense of total heartfelt conviction !
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 11:42 am

Name: J.P. Leary
Occupation: Publishing
City: New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 11:54 am

Name: S. M. Shahed
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 12:18 pm

Name: Smita Botre
Occupation: Horticulturist
City: London, Country: GB
Comments: I fully support the petition. I have seen myself 'In the name of god' and i see no reason not to screen it anywhere in the world. I am very sorry to say that people who do not agree are rather defensive, unreasonable and narrow minded.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 12:24 pm

Name: Bhavana Padiyath
Occupation: Researcher
City: Cambridge, Country: GB
Comments: Those who oppose Anand's films and views ought to do so by providing counter arguments. Suppressing his right to express himself is not the answer.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 13:05 pm

Name: Jess Hart
Occupation:
City: Bellevue, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 13:19 pm

Name: Betty Chan
Occupation:
City: san francisco, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 13:29 pm

Name: Baljit Kaur
Occupation: University Teacher
City: Christchurch, Country: NZ
Comments: Humanity faces a bleak future indeed if the chances for fearless debate on the issues plaguing us get obstructed just because some people might be made uneasy by some views. To stifle free expression of multiple views will not get us far.
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 14:08 pm

Name: Russell Johannesson
Occupation: Unemployed Computer Programmer
City: San Leandro, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 15:20 pm

Name: Sheila Ghose
Occupation:
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 17:24 pm

Name: Irma Avila Pietrasanta
Occupation: Filmaker
City: Mexico, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 19:16 pm

Name: Ram Rahman
Occupation: Photographer
City: New Delhi/New York, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 19:22 pm

Name: Jiten Vaidya
Occupation: Software Engineer
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 20:36 pm

Name: Rondi Gilbert
Occupation: University Teacher
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 22:12 pm

Name: Umesh Patil
Occupation: Software Engineer
City: San Jose, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 23:13 pm

Name: Sukumaran K
Occupation: Social Activist
City: Badwani, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 23:20 pm

Name: Irum Shiekh
Occupation:
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-26-02 Time: 23:50 pm

Name: Samuel Asir Raj S.
Occupation: Environmental activist, documentary film maker, lecturer
City: Ambasamudram, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 01:25 am

Name: Jayant B.Joshi
Occupation: Graphic Designer & Painter.
City: Pune, Country: IN
Comments: I cherish Freedom,respect expressions, love likeminded persons.Every view/point must be heard/seen,displayed to the young. Sincere expressions should not be supressed.
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 01:29 am

Name: Shyam Menon
Occupation: Academic
City: Delhi, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 01:40 am

Name: Mark Reade McKenna
Occupation:
City: San Francisco, Country: US
Comments: I strongly endorse the screening of Mr. Patwardhan's provocative and thoughtful work.
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 04:47 am

Name: J. Davis
Occupation: Self Employed
City: Branford, Country: US
Comments: We believe in free speech
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 06:43 am

Name: David Fujino
Occupation: Actor/writer/artist
City: Toronto, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 09:12 am

Name: Starr Austin
Occupation: writer/artist
City: Springdale, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 10:08 am

Name: Amara Westheimer
Occupation: student
City: Hartford, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 10:41 am

Name: Sharmila Roy
Occupation: Attorney
City: Naperville, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 10:41 am

Name: Rashmi Sadana
Occupation: Student
City: --, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 12:59 pm

Name: Sanjeev Bery
Occupation: Fundraiser
City: Berkeley, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 13:10 pm

Name: Dimple Abichandani
Occupation: student
City: Cambridge, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 14:23 pm

Name: fabrizia baldissera
Occupation: University professor
City: Florence, Country: IT
Comments: I love and admire Anand Patwardhan's films, and would feel very deprived if any of us were deprived of the experience of seeing them.
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 14:29 pm

Name: Harris Parnell
Occupation: Community Organizer
City: Portland,, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 16:06 pm

Name: Abhijeet Paul
Occupation: Research
City: Kolkata, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 18:57 pm

Name: Vinay Lal
Occupation: professor of history
City: Los Angeles, Country: US
Comments: Anand Patwardhan's films are thoughtful, probing examinations of violence and other social problems in contemporary Indian society, and attempts to silence him, in whatsoever fashion they may be attempted, must be unequovically condemned.
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 20:19 pm

Name: Shanth V. Mannige
Occupation: Business
City: Pune, Country: IN
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 20:31 pm

Name: Himani Bannerji
Occupation:
City: --, Country: CA
Comments:
Date: 01-27-02 Time: 20:46 pm

Name: Kyle Tucker
Occupation: writer
City: --, Country: US
Comments: It takes real cowards to be afraid of a movie.
Date: 01-28-02 Time: 02:24 am

Name: Ammu Abraham
Occupation: Feminist activist Women's Centre, Bombay
City: Mumbai, Country: IN
Comments: No need to hide my name or that of the organization. Comment: You should perhaps highlight the fact that Ramanand Sagar's soap opera on Ramayana is being shown anyway at the exhibition; so there is no reason not to show Anant Patwardhan's.
Date: 01-28-02 Time: 02:48 am

Name: Apratim Chatterji
Occupation: Research Student
City: Bangalore, Country: US
Comments:
Date: 01-28-02 Time: 03:42 am

Name: Nadarajah Manickam
Occupation: Lecturer
City: Kuala Lumpur, Country: MY
Comments: AP's films will provide a "deep